Back to Blog
Shoffi TeamBy Shoffi Team

5 Customer Acquisition Channels for Shopify Apps: Pros vs. Cons

You probably already know the different acquisition channels for your Shopify app, but which ones are better for you? Let's break down the pros and cons of each.

5 Customer Acquisition Channels for Shopify Apps: Pros vs. Cons

You probably already know the different acquisition channels for your Shopify app, but which ones are better for you? Let's explore the main channels and weigh their advantages and disadvantages to help you make an informed decision.

🏪

Shopify App Store

Most Shopify apps, especially small and medium-sized ones, rely heavily on this channel. The users who visit your listing page have a strong buying intent – they have a Shopify store and are actively looking for a specific solution.

If your app ranks high in search results and addresses the user's problem effectively, you have a very high chance of getting an install.

The challenge? It's not getting any easier out there. More and more apps are competing for the exact same keywords, and a few "giants" from every category, with a very high number of reviews, attract most of the traffic.

The latest changes to the app store bring good news for smaller apps, with the new "recommendations" section of similar apps at the bottom of the page. If Shopify's algorithm works as expected, you have a better chance to capture some traffic from the dominant players.

Pros & Cons
  • Free to list and get discovered
  • High conversion rate from intent-driven visitors
  • Slow progress in building visibility
  • Difficult to rank high against established competitors
📝

Content Marketing (Social/SEO)

While seeing results from organic traffic can take a while, it's probably one of the most reliable acquisition channels for a Shopify app.

Whether it's by writing a blog that adds value to your target audience (yes, we're doing it right now!) on your website or by posting relevant content on Twitter/Facebook communities – organic content builds lasting visibility.

Organic reach through content is a very reliable channel once you reach the point where you're highly ranked on search engines or when you have gained enough relevant followers and become an "expert" in the eyes of your audience.

Pros & Cons
  • Free to create and publish
  • Builds reliable, long-term traffic
  • Very slow progress – takes months to see results
💰

Paid Ads

Let's split this channel into two main groups: Push and Pull.

Push Ads

Push ads mean buying media on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, or Google Display Network. It's the "easiest" way to reach new customers – the more you spend, the more reach you have. But reach isn't enough. The actual conversion rate is what matters.

Push ads typically have a very low conversion rate, as it's not easy to sell a specific solution to someone scrolling their Facebook feed and minding their own business. These platforms are best suited for remarketing campaigns.

Pull Ads

Pull ads are displayed to users only after they show intent, for example, Google Search ads or Shopify App Store ads. Pull ads have a better conversion rate by nature. For Shopify apps that generally provide a specific solution, these ads are much more recommended.

Push Ads
  • Scalable – increase budget, increase reach
  • Quick reach to large audiences
  • Expensive for sustained campaigns
  • Low conversion rate for cold audiences
Pull Ads
  • High conversion rate from intent-based targeting
  • Limited scalability – finite search volume
  • Can be expensive in competitive niches
🤝

Partner/Affiliate Program

Yes, we're an affiliate program platform. We're biased, but let us explain why this channel is special.

Offering a partner program adds a unique value that no other channel can provide. It allows you to add partners to your own sales team – partners whom Shopify merchants already know and trust.

When you offer an actual benefit (in the form of commissions or better support), you're recruiting the most important partners in the Shopify ecosystem to join your side.

In addition, partners who recommend your app to their clients are much more invested in making sure merchants use your app correctly and for a longer time. This helps you reduce support tickets as your partners handle installations and explain how to use your app effectively.

Our platform, Shoffi, provides a complete affiliate system for Shopify apps and a marketplace where affiliates can discover your partner program and request to join.

Pros & Cons
  • Scalable with no upfront cost
  • Highly trusted by merchants
  • Reduces support tickets
  • Attracts high-LTV customers
  • Requires paying commissions to affiliates
💬

Word Of Mouth

Similar to the affiliate program, a recommendation from one merchant to another carries very high trust.

This kind of recommendation typically happens on social media communities such as Reddit's r/Shopify or the Shopify Community forums, where merchants ask each other for advice.

Few things feel better than seeing a merchant you don't know recommend your app to another merchant. That's when you know you're doing something right.

However, this channel remains a very small piece of the overall pie and is difficult to scale intentionally.

Pros & Cons
  • Completely free
  • High-quality, intent-driven traffic
  • Highly trusted by fellow merchants
  • Very difficult to scale

Conclusion

With different pros and cons for each channel, the important thing to remember is that you can use them all. If you have the resources, you should invest in both long-term channels like SEO while also getting instant traffic from paid ads.

If you're more limited in resources, we recommend choosing to invest in specific channels based on your capability and advantages. Always remember that it's better to use fewer channels and invest in them properly than to try to use all of them and end up with average results across the board.

Your new potential customers are out there – go get them!